Going against the grind of many here but bear with me.
PGOTY:
Metro: Last Light - I absolutely loved Metro 2033 and admitted it had some serious flaws. I believe Last Light improved on almost all flaws or at least touched base on them all and then some. The graphics are amazing on PC and I highly enjoy the post-apocalyptic scenario games like STALKER. This is my personal GOTY simply because it's the only game I sat down and played through almost literally in one sitting.
Honorable mentions:
Zelda: A Link Between Worlds - Love this game and it has replaced A Link to the Past as my top favorite Zelda game because they recreated the magic of the first adding extra elements that are super fun. Not a fan of handhelds, but this game is great. Played with 3D off though, cause the implementation was terrible IMO.
Crysis 3 - Best of the series IMO and is stunning to look at. A different approach at a shoot-em-up. Just a fun no brainer to just run and gun in which I enjoy every once in a while.
Farcry 3 Blood Dragon - Yea, this game was hilarious, fun, and didn't require the main game so I purchased it super cheap. Don't really need to say more.
Most Disappointing - (Don't hate) Battlefield 4. Yes, this game actually has improved on BF3 in many ways but I still think it's too soon and can argue till I'm blue in the face about their DLC ********. It's fun, but on a personal level it's very disappointing to me because it wasn't that jump up like 1942 to 2 to 3. No I wasn't expecting a **** ton of improvement graphically or anything, but IMO still not a 60+ (100+ for Premium) dollar game to me. Just try to remember, that's just my personal opinion and I'm a huge Battlefield fan.
If you're wondering why I didn't mention the usuals.
Infinite, not a fan of the Bioshock series. I have tried to play all 3 and didn't get very far in either of them.
GTA V, again, not a fan of the series. Last GTA I really played was 3 and only ever installed 4 to benchmark it.
Any console exclusive....I don't play consoles lol and don't own a PS3.
Tomb Raider, I just could not get into this game. It was probably because I was dealing with a lot of crap at the time and at a later date will try again.