Hello everyone,
I'm on a similar situation but I already bought the macbook over a week ago. However I still have 2 days to change my mind and return it.
What I like about about the macbook multitouch is the clean interface. Finder works very well as does the aqua theme. The dock is nice too although by default magnifying is disabled so i kept it this way so it's clean but nothing new.
As far as software iLife 09 is nice and I occasionally use iMovie to do a youtube video here and there also iSight is nice too. For writing I use a software called Scrivener which does a very nice job. I also have microsoft office but there's nothing special about that.
Now I was considering switching to an Asus laptop with Windows 7 if I decide to go ahead. I'm not thrilled with the same vista style programs list.
The new dock seems interesting and I've seen on reviews on youtube that some people people prefer the Windows 7 dock to the Snow Leopard one. So it is an improvement. There a few features like windows preview and resizing your windows by sliding them to the top and edges of the screen but I don't think I'll be using those very much.
In hardware PC is always a winner they offer more for the money such as bigger hard drive, ram and graphics card so that is a plus. I might occasionally want to play a game or two but I like that mac doesn't have a major game capability because I don't procrastinate as much.
As far as software there seems to be some writing software alternatives to Scrivener which I might be interested in trying but I'm not looking forward to learning a new text editor.
I do have a gripe about mac that in my school macs don't connect properly to the Cisco Access point so that's a draw back. I need internet when I'm working on a project and the computer labs are always full.
On the other hand I really like the longer battery life of the macbook around 6 hours give or take. This is a great feature because 3 hours does not cut it anymore. I'm not sure how the Asus batteries measure up however.
So please help me out I have until Tuesday to decide to switch or not.