I've got mixed feelings about Open Box from Newegg. Just recently purchased a X1900XT card for 169.00 that had horrible tearing when I played games...2D was fine. I had to RMA and paid 25.00 restocking fee...and had to settle for a 1650Pro...not quite the same card.
At the same time I purchased an Intel 965 board for 50.00 and everything worked great...even went to the Intel site and purchased an IO shield for 4.00.
Go figure....sometimes it works out...always taking a a chance though.